Skip to Accessibility Tools Skip to Content Skip to Footer
a heart using an inhaler

Cardiac Asthma — What You Need to Know

Have you ever heard of a condition called “cardiac asthma”? Have you wondered if it’s the same as the asthma of the airways you and/or your grandchildren have been dealing with? Or maybe it’s a complication of your asthma that you may be at risk for developing?

Actually, none of those are true. Cardiac asthma is a totally separate condition from bronchial asthma. In fact, it’s more a set of symptoms than it is an actual medical diagnosis. It’s not really even asthma, despite the term commonly used. Let’s take a closer look.

What is cardiac asthma?

Cardiac asthma is a term coined by a medical doctor named James Hope back in 1833. He used it to describe inadequate oxygenation of blood and the breathlessness that comes from that.1 Although it is often confused with the more common bronchial asthma, physicians today understand that there are some essential differences between the two conditions.

How cardiac asthma and bronchial asthma are different

The main difference is that cardiac asthma is not really asthma at all. Rather, it is a set of symptoms that are similar to those caused by true asthma, but with a different root cause. Other differences include:

  • Asthma, which is sometimes referred to as “bronchial asthma,” is caused by inflammation of the airways. This is generally in response to allergens, substances that cause an allergic reaction. Or sometimes, the inflammation can be triggered by environmental factors, such as strong fumes, air pollution, or tobacco smoke.
  • Cardiac asthma symptoms are caused by congestion in the lungs that is the result of heart failure.1
  • Bronchial asthma is more common in children, although it can occur at any age. On the other hand, cardiac asthma symptoms are more common in older adults, who are more likely to have heart problems.
  • Experts are not sure what causes bronchial asthma, although there does seem to be a genetic link in many cases. In cardiac asthma, the heart’s inability to pump blood out of the left ventricle causes fluid to back up into the lungs. There can be various reasons why the heart fails to pump effectively.

How cardiac asthma and bronchial asthma are similar

Both conditions have similar symptoms, namely:1,2

Also, the symptoms in both conditions tend to be worse at night, while sleeping and lying flat. And, although these symptoms may be somewhat similar, with cardiac asthma, the patient may cough up watery or frothy sputum. This does not happen with bronchial asthma.1

It’s important to note that while the root cause of cardiac asthma is different than bronchial asthma, there can be a bit of a crossover between the 2 conditions. That is, while the backup of fluid in the lungs can cause breathing difficulties, it may also trigger a narrowing or blockage of the airways themselves. Experts believe the airways may actually become hyperreactive in cardiac asthma, similarly to what happens in bronchial asthma.1 We are not sure exactly why this happens.

However, because the root cause of cardiac asthma symptoms is not inflammation, diagnosis and treatment will be much different.

Diagnosing cardiac asthma

Cardiac asthma often causes a sudden awakening with severe shortness of breath. If the patient sits up straight for 20 to 30 minutes, the symptoms often subside on their own.1 Typically, a severe bronchial asthma attack will not subside without the use of a rescue, or quick-relief, inhaler.

Sometimes, the cardiac asthma patient will wake up several times in a single night. The symptoms can become progressively worse, including:1

  • Cyanosis (blue-tinged skin, lips or fingernails)
  • Cold sweats
  • Coughing up blood-tinged mucus

Diagnosing cardiac asthma is not as easy as it might seem. Not only are many of the symptoms similar to bronchial asthma, they are also similar to congestive heart failure. Wheezing is considered a hallmark symptom of cardiac asthma vs. heart failure alone, though.1

Chest x-rays, a thorough medical history, and other cardiac tests can help the doctor figure out exactly what the patient is dealing with.

Treatment approaches

Because the root cause of cardiac asthma is not inflammation, treatment is totally different. Inhaled steroids, bronchodilators, and other typical asthma medications are not useful with this condition.

Instead, treatment focuses on relieving the underlying heart issues that led to the fluid build-up in the lungs. This may include diuretics to remove the fluid. Nitroglycerin and morphine may also be used to reduce the stress on the heart.

Supplemental oxygen may be used in some cases. Proper positioning while sleeping is also crucial. In other words, the head of the bed should be raised in some way to avoid the patient lying flat. During an acute episode, the patient may even need to stand or sit completely erect with feet hanging below heart level.1,3

The symptoms of cardiac asthma should not be taken lightly, as they can be life-threatening. This is why it’s important to distinguish this from the generally less severe bronchial asthma. The good news is that prompt, intensive treatment can lead to rapid, positive improvement.

In summary

It’s never wise to try and diagnose yourself. Just because you are having some of the hallmark symptoms of asthma, doesn’t mean you really have asthma. If you are having wheezing, shortness of breath and coughing, especially if those symptoms wake you up suddenly while sleeping, it’s time to consult your doctor.

This is especially true if you are an older adult and if you have any history of heart problems. It could be that what you are experiencing is really the syndrome known as cardiac asthma, which isn’t really asthma at all.

Poll

This article represents the opinions, thoughts, and experiences of the author; none of this content has been paid for by any advertiser. The Asthma.net team does not recommend or endorse any products or treatments discussed herein. Learn more about how we maintain editorial integrity here.

  1. Litzinger MHJ, Aluyen JKN, Cereceres R, Feik A, et al. Cardiac Asthma: Not Your Typical Asthma. US Pharm. 2013;38(2):HS-12-HS-18.
  2. Cardiac asthma: What causes it?. Mankad R. May Clinic website. https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/heart-failure/expert-answers/cardiac-asthma/faq-20058447. Accessed 26 December 2019.
  3. Tanabe T, Rozycki HJ, Kanoh S, Rubin BK. Cardiac asthma: new insights into an old disease. Expert Rev Respir Med. 2012 Dec;6(6):705-14. doi: 10.1586/ers.12.67.

Comments

  • Shellzoo
    1 week ago

    Just after my dad died, my mother had heart failure. It was a side effect from her blood pressure medication combined with grief. Her symptoms were like asthma. Short of breath, wheezing, fatigue. I took her immediately to urgent care where they did quite a few tests and discovered the heart failure. It resolved after the blood pressure medication was changed. This is a good article.

  • Leon Lebowitz, RRT moderator
    1 week ago

    Hi Shellzoo, and thanks for your comment here in response to Kathi’s excellent presentation of cardiac asthma.

    I’m glad to hear your mother is doing okay now. It’s not easy to lose one’s one’s dad/husband. Please accept my condolences for this loss for you and your mom.

    We appreciate your candor, Shellzoo.

    Warmly,
    Leon (site moderator asthma.net)

  • Leon Lebowitz, RRT moderator
    1 week ago

    Hi Kathi, and thanks so much for having this published. It’s an excellent article on a topic that is often misunderstood. The two conditions (as you well pointed out), are sometimes even confused and with one another.
    Your article goes a long way towards explaining what this is all about. It will be a good one to use as a reference/guide.
    Regards,
    Leon (site moderator asthma.net)

  • Poll